top of page

The Art of Screenwriting: Nicole Holofcener

For any aspiring writer entering the field, writing a complete script is a daunting task not everyone can accomplish. Developing a compelling plot with a low likelihood of success requires considerable time, dedication, and more. Regardless of your genre preference or aspirations, Nicole Holofcener is a great writer to analyze.

Holofcener has been one of the leading voices in American indie cinema since her debut feature film, Walking and Talking, in 1996. Having recently released the comedy-drama You Hurt My Feelings (2023), Holofcener has a lot to offer regarding longevity, writing styles, the importance of characters, and more.

Photo credit: Ella Kemp


Holofcener frequently explores themes related to herself in her films, with a recurring fear of rejection. That ability to share some relatability is connected to realism in film. Generally, her films hinge on both narrative and visual authenticity.

Realism aims to establish a feeling of familiarity, relatability, and emotional resonance among the audience, fostering a connection that allows them to engage with the on-screen world on a personal and authentic level. Holofcener does so brilliantly, from Amelia’s anxiety and insecurity in Walking and Talking (1996) to Don feeling self-conscious over aging in You Hurt My Feelings (2023).

In other words, the storyline must be firmly rooted in reality, and the visuals should align with that realism. These films are grounded in reality, bereft of the escapist fantasy often found in typical Hollywood blockbusters.

The Importance Of Characters

As writers, we all know about the importance of scripts. Characters propel the narrative forward and are the driving force behind the plot. How many times have we heard that lousy characters can ruin a good idea? When crafted effectively, characters can evoke a spectrum of emotions.

Characters that we can relate to allow us to glimpse aspects of ourselves through their personalities and challenges in the film. Whether they're likable or exhibit a relatable personality, they create a desire for us to meet them, hang out, or even aspire to embody their excellent qualities, as superficial as that may sound.

Holofcener approaches her characters with realism while developing them in a way that’s not a part of the usual Hollywood tropes. For example, many of her characters are authentic and multifaceted, individuals who might be dishonest and have outbursts. However, even amid the chaos of their worlds falling apart, they consistently hold onto their friendships with unwavering loyalty and love.

Authenticity and Relatability

Most of Holofcener's films exude genuineness, portraying narratives akin to those of your coworker or neighbor. Rooted in the everyday experiences of people from the middle class, her work dives into authentic stories. People entering her films can anticipate an exploration of the common challenges related to love, friendships, and the everyday existence of an average person.

Despite often adopting unconventional structures, her films are highly regarded for their meticulous character development. Holofcener unquestionably possesses a rare talent for crafting stories and characters that are both relatable and entertaining.

As you can expect, authentic characters are those audiences can relate to, and there are various archetypes. When audiences recognize themselves or the people they know in your characters, a deep emotional connection to your story is forged. Viewers will cheer for your characters during their highs and lows and celebrate their triumphs.

What Holofcener May Center Her Characters Around

1. What are their aspirations and passions? What do they yearn for above all else? These aspirations introduce conflicts and tensions into your narrative, heightening its allure. Whether your characters pursue true love, revenge, or the world's salvation, ensure their actions have a purpose.

2. What idiosyncrasies or routines do they possess? Infusing your characters with minor quirks can make them more believable.

3. What imperfections and vulnerabilities do they harbor? Remember, perfection isn’t possible. Flaws not only make characters relatable but also provide opportunities for personal growth. Every Holofcener character is flawed in some way. Watch any of her films and take note.

4. What is their origin story? Where were they born, and how did their upbringing mold them into the individuals they are today?

Best Nicole Holofcener Scripts

Walking and Talking (1996) - Just as Amelia thinks she's over her anxiety and insecurity, her best friend announces her engagement, bringing her anxiety and insecurity right back.

Can You Ever Forgive Me? (2018) - When Lee Israel falls out of step with current tastes, she turns her art form to deception.

Enough Said (2013) - A divorced woman who decides to pursue the man she's interested in learns he's her new friend's ex-husband.

Lovely & Amazing (2001) - Self-esteem and insecurity are at the heart of this comedy about the relationship between a mother and her three confused daughters.

The Last Duel (2021) - The Knight Jean de Carrouges must settle the dispute over his wife Marguerite by challenging his former friend to a duel to the death.


bottom of page